12 June 2013
Breach of Confidentiality - Ignorance can be bliss
Breach of Confidentiality - Ignorance can be bliss
An interesting question was recently decided in the case of Vestergaard Frandsen v Bestnet Europe Ltd which pondered whether an employee can be liable for breach of confidence if they start a new business with others who, without the first employee knowing about it, misuse confidential information.
Mrs Sig formerly worked for Vestergaard, a producer of mosquito nets, until she left with Mr Larsen and Dr Skovmand to form a new company in the same line of work, called 'Intection'.
It later transpired that Intection's product design was based on confidential information which Dr Skovmand had taken from Vestergaard. Mrs Sig was totally unaware of this fact until Vestergaard commenced proceedings.
The Supreme Court considered two key issues in deciding whether Mrs Sig, along with Dr Skovmand and Mr Larsen, could be liable for breach of confidence towards her former employer.
The first issue was that the express confidentiality term in Mrs Sig's contract only covered knowledge gained by her personally during her employment with Vestergaard, not the knowledge that had been gained by others.
Secondly, there was no 'common design', ie an active 'conspiracy' of which Mrs Sig was a part. It was found that she was an unknowing participant in the misuse of Vestergaard's confidential information and so was spared liability for the acts of her colleagues.
Conclusion
This case highlights that if an employer decides to pursue a group of employees for breach of restrictive covenants and/or misuse of confidential information they should be very careful as to which employees they pursue. The employer should undertake early investigatory attempts to identify the 'culprit' employee and not to take a scattered approach when issuing a claim.
There was also a brief consideration by the Court that with such cases there needs to be a balance between the protection of intellectual property and free market competition. So when your salesman leaves for a competitor, the Court will try and identify a line between the ordinary rough and tumble of business life, and serious damage to your business. Only if the latter is evident will it enforce any restrictive covenants
Intergraf Economic News (Paper Prices) - March 2024
18 March 2024
Access the latest edition of the Economic Newsletter for the European Printing Industry for data on paper consumption, and pricing data for pulp, paper and recovered paper. Data for packaging papers and board is also available with this edition.
UK to follow global expansion of inkjet printing
21 March 2024
The latest expert analysis from Smithers identifies the potential of the latest generation of inkjet systems to improve profitability across the global print market. Read more about the new report The Future of Inkjet Printing to 2029.
The BPIF is the printing industries champion. By becoming a member you join a diverse and influential community. We help you solve business problems, connect you to new customers and suppliers and make your voice heard in government.
Call 01676 526030